Question:
Are "low carbon footprint" measures actually helping?
Sarah T
2009-06-19 07:52:22 UTC
Do things such as recycling, using florescent light bulbs, buying organic, etc. actually help the environment? I couldn't figure out a good way to research this.
I want to do all the right things, but I know that there is skepticism out there and I want to know what's what.
Eight answers:
whsgreenmom
2009-06-19 19:38:22 UTC
It depends on who you ask, I say yes. The more demand there are for eco friendly products the more they will be produced. We may not have reached the point where the earth is getting cleaner, but it is getting polluted less quickly. We all have to start somewhere, the more we change wasteful or toxic methods the better off we will be. I don't use CFL's to save the world I use them to reduce my electric bill, I eat a local organic or free range diet to reduce the immediate risks to my family, and by doing so I'm helping fund local farmers to expand their organic growing and their grass fed meats.



Each day we get to vote many times, every time we purchased, use or consume something that was made in a sustainable way we are telling manufacturers that we want a better cleaner world. They can't do it if it isn't profitable, a companies purpose is to make money, lets help them do what's right for them and for us. Each time we make a better choice and someone see's us doing it we are helping change the world.
It's not magic, it's physics!
2009-06-19 15:21:58 UTC
There isn't a possible way to get an objective measurement of a "carbon footprint." It isn't possible. We barely are starting to get a feel for what kind of effect vegetation has on CO2 levels (by the way, CO2 is critical for life - the more there is, the better, as long as oxygen levels are good enough for respiration). Every time you breathe out, you put more CO2 into the air.



Actually, fluorescent light bulbs overall more harmful to the environment because they contain dangerous levels of mercury. The reason why they are being pushed as "green" is because they use less energy, and the only thing enviro-nuts care about is levels of CO2 (clearly they haven't done any research on photosynthesis - you should look it up, too. Besides, the correlation between temperature and CO2 is not only weak, but it looks more like they have it backwards). That being said, however, the amount you save on your electric bill is noticeable when you switch to fluorescent. I can't wait until they make LED's cheap enough for them to be used in home lighting. Much more environmentally friendly, less breakable, easier to clean up, use less energy, and last much longer.



Recycling is critical for having a sustainable level of resources, and helps to keep sustainable mining, extraction, and wood-harvesting practices. The most important thing is that we keep everything at a level in which the resources are ultimately infinite because they are replenished at the same rate they are expended.



Buying organic food does not help the environment, nor does it slow down any hurting of the environment. It's exactly the same as buying the non-organic stuff, only the chemical levels are slightly lower (even though the non-organic chemical levels are negligible) and the bacterial counts are significantly higher (my wife worked in a microbiology lab, and now she works in a chemistry lab at the same place. She knows).
anonymous
2009-06-19 10:46:32 UTC
I think that low carbon footprints help the environment a lot. We can not undo the damage that we have already done to our world, but we can slow it down to a point where things are a lot safer. The industrial revolution didn't cause half as many problems as we do now and we still use that same old technology from back then in many of our factories and manufacturing facilities. We can definitely take steps to help our environment, doubting methods like this is what makes these little problems happen.
piepounder
2009-06-19 08:01:27 UTC
Starbuck is right, its just a feel good thing thats hyped up by the media.
anonymous
2009-06-19 10:31:09 UTC
All laws are only as good as they are followed or implemented. But yes . . it helps and will go a long way. every minute step matters!
tubaplayer360
2009-06-19 10:26:22 UTC
they don't help the environment, they just cut down on how much we damage it
iTeal
2009-06-19 11:00:55 UTC
even if it doesn't help the environment i mean c'mon @ least we arent' hurting it more
Starbuck
2009-06-19 07:57:05 UTC
No, its just a feel good issue.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...